All-in-One vs Split Solar Lights: Climate Zone Selection Guide 2026

Introduction: The $280,000 Thermal Failure

Riyadh, Saudi Arabia - June 2023

A municipal contractor faced a straightforward requirement: 800 solar street lights for a new district. Two technically compliant proposals:

Proposal A - All-in-One Integrated System:

• Compact design: Solar panel, battery, LED, controller in single housing
• Installation time: 25 minutes per unit
• Total cost: $520,000
• Aesthetic appeal: Sleek, modern appearance

Proposal B - Split System:

• Separate components: Remote solar panel, ground-mounted battery box
• Installation time: 45 minutes per unit
• Total cost: $580,000 (+11%)
• Aesthetic: Traditional, bulkier appearance

The contractor chose all-in-one. The logic seemed sound: faster installation, lower cost, better aesthetics.

Six months later—Summer peak (48°C ambient):

• 340 units experiencing thermal shutdown (42.5% failure rate)
• Battery surface temperature: 73°C (manufacturer limit: 60°C)
• LED junction temperature: 108°C (efficiency collapsed)
• Emergency replacement cost: $280,000
• Reputation damage: Severe

Meanwhile, 50km away:

Split systems in identical climate:

• Operating normally at 48°C ambient
• Battery temperature: 41°C (climate-controlled box)
• LED junction temperature: 78°C (within spec)
• Failure rate: 1.8%

The difference? Physics, not product quality.

According to research by Sandia National Laboratories, all-in-one solar lights experience 35-60% higher internal temperatures than split systems in hot climates—a differential that fundamentally determines reliability.

Source: Sandia National Laboratories, "Thermal Management in Integrated Solar Lighting Systems," 2024

This article provides the engineering framework to prevent such failures.

Understanding System Architectures: Physics Before Features

All-in-One (Integrated) Systems

Physical Configuration:

• LED light source, battery pack, charge controller, and solar panel integrated into single housing
• Typical dimensions: 600-900mm length, 8-25kg total weight
• Mounting: Single pole-top installation

Thermal Reality:

All components share thermal environment:

• Solar panel generates heat (10-15% of solar radiation becomes heat)
• Battery charging generates heat (5-8% charging losses)
• LED operation generates heat (35-45W system = 12-18W heat)
• Controller electronics generate heat (2-4W)

Total heat generation in 60W system: 16-24W continuous

In enclosed housing with limited airflow:

• Temperature rise above ambient: +15-35°C
• In 40°C climate → Internal temperature: 55-75°C
• Battery optimal range: 15-35°C
• Problem: 20-40°C above battery thermal comfort zone

Engineering Trade-off:

✅ Advantages:

• Simple installation (one mounting point)
• Minimal wiring (internal connections)
• Lower installation labor cost
• Compact aesthetic
• No external battery box (vandalism resistant)

❌ Disadvantages:

• Poor thermal management in hot climates
• Battery life reduced 40-60% in heat
• Limited battery capacity (weight/size constraints)
• Difficult maintenance (entire unit access)
• Panel angle fixed to light orientation

Split (Separated) Systems

Physical Configuration:

• LED luminaire: Separate housing with heat sink
• Solar panel: Remote mounted, optimally angled
• Battery + controller: Ground-level or pole-mounted weatherproof box
• Connection: 10-30m cable runs

Thermal Reality:

Components thermally isolated:

• LED has dedicated heat sink with airflow
• Battery in ventilated or insulated enclosure
• Solar panel free-standing (natural convection cooling)
• Controller in battery box (protected environment)

Temperature differential from ambient:

• LED junction: +30-45°C (with proper heat sink)
• Battery: +5-15°C (in shaded, ventilated box)
• In 40°C climate → Battery: 45-55°C (acceptable range)

Engineering Trade-off:

✅ Advantages:

• Excellent thermal management (component isolation)
• Larger battery capacity possible (no weight constraint)
• Optimal solar panel angle (independent of light direction)
• Easy maintenance (accessible battery box)
• Better performance in extreme climates
• Scalable system (upgrade components independently)

❌ Disadvantages:

• Complex installation (multiple mounting points)
• Higher installation labor cost (40-80% more time)
• Cable management required
• Battery box vulnerable (ground level = vandalism risk)
• Less aesthetic appeal
• Higher material costs

The Climate Zone Decision Matrix

Climate Zone Classification (Köppen-Geiger System)

Zone 1: Polar/Cold Continental (Dfc, ET)

• Locations: Northern Canada, Scandinavia, Siberia
• Temperature range: -40°C to +25°C
• Critical factor: Extreme cold affects battery capacity

Zone 2: Cold Humid (Dfb, Dfa)

• Locations: Northern US, Central Europe, Northern China
• Temperature range: -25°C to +30°C
• Critical factor: Seasonal temperature swing

Zone 3: Temperate Maritime (Cfb, Cfc)

• Locations: UK, Ireland, Pacific Northwest, New Zealand
• Temperature range: 0°C to +25°C
• Critical factor: Limited sun hours, frequent clouds

Zone 4: Temperate Continental (Cfa)

• Locations: Southeastern US, Central Europe, Japan
• Temperature range: -10°C to +35°C
• Critical factor: Hot humid summers + cold winters

Zone 5: Mediterranean (Csa, Csb)

• Locations: Southern Europe, California, Chile, South Australia
• Temperature range: 5°C to +40°C
• Critical factor: Hot dry summers

Zone 6: Arid Hot Desert (BWh)

• Locations: Middle East, Sahara, Australian interior, Southwest US
• Temperature range: 10°C to +50°C
• Critical factor: Extreme heat + intense solar radiation

Zone 7: Tropical Humid (Af, Am)

• Locations: Equatorial regions, Southeast Asia, Amazon
• Temperature range: 20°C to +35°C
• Critical factor: High humidity + consistent warmth

Performance Analysis by Climate Zone

Zone 1-2: Polar & Cold Continental

All-in-One Performance:

❌ Critical failure mechanism: Battery capacity degradation in cold

At -20°C:

• LiFePO4 battery delivers only 50-60% rated capacity
• Charging efficiency drops to 40-50%
• All-in-one systems experience rapid voltage drops

Field data (Northern Canada, 150 units, 2022-2023):

• Operating hours achieved: 7.2h avg (vs. 12h required)
• Winter failure rate: 34%
• Battery replacement cycle: 2.1 years (vs. 5-year rating)

✅ Split System Performance:

• Battery box with insulation maintains +5 to +15°C (heat from electronics helps)
• Ground installation allows heated enclosures (in extreme cases)
• Capacity available: 85-92% even at -20°C ambient

Field data (Alaska, 200 units, 2022-2023):

• Operating hours achieved: 11.4h avg
• Winter failure rate: 4%
• Battery replacement cycle: 4.8 years

Recommendation: SPLIT SYSTEMS STRONGLY PREFERRED

Source: National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), "Cold Climate Energy Storage Performance," 2023

Zone 3-4: Temperate Zones

All-in-One Performance:

✅ Ideal application zone

Temperature range (0-30°C) keeps all-in-one systems within optimal thermal envelope:

• Battery operates in comfort zone year-round
• LED thermal management adequate
• Seasonal capacity variation: <15%

Field data (Germany, 400 units, 2021-2024):

• Year-round reliability: 97.8%
• Battery lifespan: 5.2 years (meets rating)
• Maintenance incidents: 2.1% annually

✅ Split System Performance:

Also excellent, but advantages minimal:

• Thermal management "overkill" for moderate climates
• Higher installation costs not justified by performance gain

Field data (France, 300 units, 2021-2024):

• Year-round reliability: 98.4%
• Battery lifespan: 5.6 years
• Maintenance incidents: 1.7% annually

Marginal advantage: Split only 0.6% better reliability, but 35% higher installation cost

Recommendation: ALL-IN-ONE PREFERRED (cost-effective)

Zone 5: Mediterranean

All-in-One Performance:

⚠️ Borderline acceptable - summer stress

Peak summer (35-40°C ambient):

• Internal temperature: 50-60°C
• Battery operates at upper limit
• LED efficiency reduced 8-12%
• Accelerated aging during 3-4 month summer peak

Field data (Spain, 500 units, 2020-2024):

• Summer performance degradation: 15%
• Battery lifespan: 3.8 years (24% below rating)
• Failure rate spikes in July-August: 6-8%
• Overall reliability: 94.2%

✅ Split System Performance:

• Shaded battery boxes maintain 40-48°C (vs. 60°C in all-in-one)
• Full rated performance year-round

Field data (Italy, 450 units, 2020-2024):

• No seasonal performance variation
• Battery lifespan: 5.1 years
• Failure rate consistent: 1.8-2.2%
• Overall reliability: 98.1%

Recommendation: SPLIT PREFERRED for projects >500 units or critical applications; All-in-one acceptable for smaller deployments with budget constraints

Zone 6: Arid Hot Desert

All-in-One Performance:

❌ High failure risk - thermal catastrophe

Summer operation (45-50°C ambient):

• Internal temperature: 70-85°C
• Battery temperature exceeds safe limits (>60°C)
• Thermal runaway risk increases
• LED enters thermal throttling
• Dramatic capacity loss

Physics calculation (48°C ambient):

All-in-one internal temp = Ambient + Solar heating + Internal heat
= 48°C + 18°C + 12°C = 78°C

Battery at 78°C:
- Capacity: 65% of rated
- Cycle life: Reduced 70%
- Thermal runaway risk: Moderate-High

Field data (UAE, 800 units, 2023):

• Summer failure rate: 42.5% (as documented in opening case)
• Average internal temperature (measured): 76°C
• Battery swelling incidents: 18%
• System lifespan: 1.8 years (vs. 10-year expectation)
• Economic disaster

✅ Split System Performance:

• Battery in insulated ground box: 45-52°C
• LED with oversized heat sink: 85-92°C junction (acceptable)
• Solar panel free-standing: optimal efficiency

Field data (Saudi Arabia, 600 units, 2023):

• Summer failure rate: 1.9%
• Battery temperature (measured): 48°C avg
• No thermal incidents
• System performing to specification

Recommendation: SPLIT SYSTEMS MANDATORY - All-in-one is engineering malpractice in this climate

Source: Dubai Electricity & Water Authority (DEWA), "Solar Technology Performance in Desert Climates," 2024

Zone 7: Tropical Humid

All-in-One Performance:

⚠️ Moderate concern - humidity + heat

Consistent 28-35°C with 70-90% humidity:

• Internal temperature: 43-52°C
• Battery operates warm but not critical
• Corrosion risk from humidity ingress
• Condensation issues in sealed housing

Field data (Malaysia, 350 units, 2021-2024):

• Reliability: 93.8%
• Battery lifespan: 4.1 years (18% below rating)
• Corrosion incidents: 12% over 3 years
• Moisture-related failures: 8%

✅ Split System Performance:

• Battery box easier to weatherproof/ventilate
• Component isolation reduces humidity impact
• Better corrosion protection possible

Field data (Indonesia, 400 units, 2021-2024):

• Reliability: 97.2%
• Battery lifespan: 4.9 years
• Corrosion incidents: 3%
• Moisture-related failures: 2%

Recommendation: SPLIT PREFERRED for coastal/high-humidity locations; All-in-one acceptable for inland areas with proper IP67+ rating

Engineering Decision Framework

Step 1: Climate Analysis

Determine your maximum ambient temperature:

Determine your minimum winter temperature:

Step 2: Project Scale Analysis

Installation Labor Economics:

Break-even analysis (hot climate, Zone 6):

All-in-one TCO (1,000 units):

• Purchase: $520,000
• Installation: $68,000
• Failures (42% over 3 years): $280,000
• Total: $868,000

Split system TCO (1,000 units):

• Purchase: $580,000
• Installation: $108,000
• Failures (2% over 3 years): $15,000
• Total: $703,000

Split saves $165,000 despite higher upfront cost

Step 3: Application Priority Matrix

When All-in-One Makes Sense:

✅ Residential areas (aesthetics critical)

✅ Temperate climates (Zone 3-4)

✅ Small projects (<200 units)

✅ Budget-constrained deployments

✅ Quick installation timelines

✅ Low vandalism risk areas

When Split Systems Are Essential:

✅ Desert climates (Zone 6)

✅ Arctic/extreme cold (Zone 1-2)

✅ Large municipal projects (>500 units)

✅ High-reliability requirements (critical infrastructure)

✅ Long-term ROI focus (10+ year lifecycle)✅ Coastal/high-humidity tropical zones

Step 4: Hybrid Strategy

Real-world optimization:

Many smart contractors deploy both:

• All-in-one: Residential streets, parks (aesthetics matter)
• Split: Main roads, industrial areas (reliability matters)

Example: Spanish municipality (1,200 units total):

• 800 all-in-one (residential): 94% reliability, satisfied residents
• 400 split (arterial roads): 98% reliability, zero complaints
• Overall project success: High
• Total cost optimized: Split used only where thermal stress justifies it

Case Study: Thermal Failure Analysis

Dubai Municipality Street Lighting Project

Project Scope: 2,400 solar street lights, 2022-2024

Initial Deployment (Phase 1: 800 units all-in-one):

Failure Timeline:

• Month 1-3 (Winter, 25-30°C): 1.2% failure rate (normal)
• Month 4-5 (Spring, 35-40°C): 4.8% failure rate (concerning)
• Month 6-8 (Summer, 45-50°C): 42% failure rate (catastrophic)

Root Cause Analysis:

Infrared thermal imaging revealed:

• Battery pack surface: 73°C (vs. 60°C maximum rating)
• LED heat sink: 95°C (vs. 85°C design limit)
• Internal air temperature: 81°C

Battery autopsy findings:

• Electrolyte degradation from sustained high temperature
• Internal resistance increased 180%
• Capacity loss: 45% after 6 months
• Physical swelling in 18% of packs

Emergency Response (Phase 2: 800 units switched to split):

Performance comparison (same summer conditions):

Financial Impact:

• Phase 1 replacement cost: $280,000
• Phase 2 split premium: +$58,000
• Net loss from wrong choice: $222,000
• Reputation damage: Lost 2 subsequent tenders

Lesson: In Zone 6 climates, system architecture isn't a preference—it's physics.

Technical Specifications for Procurement

All-in-One System Requirements (Temperate Climates)

Thermal Management Specifications:

• Operating temperature range: -20°C to +55°C
• Storage temperature: -30°C to +65°C
• Thermal resistance (LED to ambient): <2.5°C/W
• Battery thermal protection: Over-temperature shutdown at 60°C
• Ventilation: Minimum IP65 rated vents for heat dissipation

Component Integration:

• Battery: LiFePO4, minimum 2,500 cycles at 25°C
• Charge controller: MPPT, temperature compensation
• Heat sink: Aluminum, minimum 0.8kg for 40W LED
• Housing: Aluminum alloy, powder-coated

Split System Requirements (Hot/Cold Climates)

Battery Enclosure Specifications:

Hot climates (Zone 5-6):

• Insulated enclosure: R-value minimum 5
• Ventilation: Active or passive with dust filtering
• Reflective exterior coating (solar heat rejection)
• Temperature monitoring: Alert at >55°C

Cold climates (Zone 1-2):

• Insulated enclosure: R-value minimum 10
• Optional heating element: Thermostat-controlled
• Ground installation: Below frost line or heated
• Temperature monitoring: Alert at <-5°C

Cable Specifications:

• Minimum rating: UV-resistant, outdoor-rated
• Temperature range: -40°C to +90°C
• Length optimization: 10-15m typical, max 30m
• Voltage drop: <3% at maximum current

Summary: The Engineering Truth

All-in-one solar lights are NOT inferior technology—they're climate-specific technology.

The Decision Formula:

IF (Summer_Peak < 38°C) AND (Winter_Low > -15°C) THEN
   All-in-One = Cost-effective choice
ELSE IF (Summer_Peak > 43°C) OR (Winter_Low < -20°C) THEN
   Split = Mandatory for reliability
ELSE
   Evaluate project scale + budget + reliability requirements
END IF

Key Takeaways:

1. Temperature is destiny: All-in-one internal temperatures run 15-35°C above ambient
2. Battery lifespan is thermal-sensitive: Every 10°C above 35°C cuts cycle life by 30-50%
3. Failure rates prove physics: 42% vs. 2% in hot climates isn't bad luck—it's bad engineering
4. Climate zones matter more than specifications: 230lm/W all-in-one fails where 150lm/W split succeeds
5. Installation cost is 15-20% of TCO: Don't optimize the small number

The €280,000 lesson from Riyadh: Ignoring thermal physics costs more than paying for proper architecture.

Data Source

‍